I found a bunch of gold! I'm rich!

Well, now what

  • Change the oil, run it a few more miles, check again

    Votes: 32 78.0%
  • Pull it apart.

    Votes: 9 22.0%

  • Total voters
    41
Oct 8, 2023 #584
The composite gears are not so bad as people think.

Several years ago went a few rounds with a 351W in a fine '69 Mustang, CC hyd roller, don't know about the oil pump, but it ate three bronze gears, all from CC. The 2nd and 3rd were showing rapid wear in just a few miles so were changed immediately. The 4th gear is a composite from CC and it has been in use continually since in the sunny day daily driver / track day toy.

I guarantee the gears were all installed correctly to the depth and shaft end clearance required in FoMoCo specs and the block dimension was double checked.

Because of the circus with the bronze gears we pulled the plastic gear several times in a few miles, few days, few months, and the next two annual oil changes, and not a bit of wear, it literally didn't look like it had been run at all.

.........

but it's a lot easier to repeat internet shitalk than what you don't know first hand
We run the composite gear on our Pontiac builds but the Pontiac is lucky to have a pipe thread plug you can drill in the galley with a small hole to squirt oil on the distributor gear, it is in line with the gear and works perfectly to oil it.
 
Oct 8, 2023 #584
The composite gears are not so bad as people think.

Several years ago went a few rounds with a 351W in a fine '69 Mustang, CC hyd roller, don't know about the oil pump, but it ate three bronze gears, all from CC. The 2nd and 3rd were showing rapid wear in just a few miles so were changed immediately. The 4th gear is a composite from CC and it has been in use continually since in the sunny day daily driver / track day toy.

I guarantee the gears were all installed correctly to the depth and shaft end clearance required in FoMoCo specs and the block dimension was double checked.

Because of the circus with the bronze gears we pulled the plastic gear several times in a few miles, few days, few months, and the next two annual oil changes, and not a bit of wear, it literally didn't look like it had been run at all.

.........

but it's a lot easier to repeat internet shitalk than what you don't know first hand
I will respond to the king of shit talk with facts. First , congratulations on going a few rounds several years ago ,thats quite the accomplishment , no...really it is

Comp Cams personally told me their composite dist gears are junk.
I have an MSD bronze gear on my MSD adjustable collar dist for the last 10 years / 1500 + passes . And it looks fine. Every winter I say to myself " I should change that gear, but I never do.
That is not " internet shit talk " I know it first hand
 
Last edited:
I will respond to the king of shit talk with facts. First , congratulations on going a few rounds several years ago ,thats quite the accomplishment , no...really it is

Comp Cams personally told me their composite dist gears are junk.
I have an MSD bronze gear on my MSD adjustable collar dist for the last 10 years / 1500 + passes . And it looks fine. Every winter I say to myself " I should change that gear, but I never do.
That is not " internet shit talk " I know it first hand
You don't know if you're punched or bored. They should have told you their cams are junk. Nobody is talking to you. Everybody knows those worthless MSD bronze gears don't last more than 15 minutes. You can shit talk to yourself all you want, but apologize to 89 Fox 351 for your meaningless shit talking about your Chevroeleigh which has no meaning in any way, shape, or form, nothing to do say but shit talk, in his 351 Ford thread.
 
What's amusing about this...

I started a thread years ago about needing break in oil or not. The members of the forum would say you absolutely need break in oil or an additive for the first few hundred. Same members would later say check the oil and filter after 50 miles then put in your oil of choice.

I wish I would keep a running tally of the members going backwards on previous recommendations.

Its the mob mentality. Jump on because others jump on. Reminds of the Garry threads or the hugh/dually threads.

I take the advice of very few from here, but making a thread keeps half the place entertained for 2 days.
No mob mentality here man. Just making a very simple recommendation which should have been done the day of or after you cut the filter open.
Not one person here knows what’s going on inside your engine. Only you can diagnose it.
 
You don't know if you're punched or bored. They should have told you their cams are junk. Nobody is talking to you. Everybody knows those worthless MSD bronze gears don't last more than 15 minutes. You can shit talk to yourself all you want, but apologize to 89 Fox 351 for your meaningless shit talking about your Chevroeleigh which has no meaning in any way, shape, or form, nothing to do say but shit talk, in his 351 Ford thread.
What ever homo , my junk is track tested and proven . Next time get someone to assemble that engine who knows WTF he is doing. , 3 gears chewed up lol.
Any time or place. How about next Saturday pit spot # 11 keystone.. pack a lunch and bring a friend . That is exactly where I will be , come and look me up. If you dislike me that much to respond to my posts the way you do you should jump on the chance to come see me. If you don't, that shows everyone the soy boy you really are. Internet tuff guy that hasa crocodile mouth and a puppy dog ass
Seriously man, congratulations on going those 3 rounds several years ago . No joke , that's amazing
 
No mob mentality here man. Just making a very simple recommendation which should have been done the day of or after you cut the filter open.
Not one person here knows what’s going on inside your engine. Only you can diagnose it.

Oh no, don't get me wrong, you and raid are not who I'm referring to. There are some non car having, non car building guys here giving advice and flip flopping on that advice over the years just because someone posted before them and felt the need to agree.

In an ironic turn of events, I started this thread because it really is a 50/50 craps shoot. Or crap chute. And I honestly was going to roll with the poll because I'm not sure I give much a fuck about the car at this moment. If she blows, oh well, I'll buy a 427 crate engine and send it. Keep the dyno sheet in the glove box (more flip floppin irony).

On another note, before I found the issue with the engine I bought myself a new Spector Dimension multiscale bass. Arrives later today.

New thread to follow.
 
Chevys have a larger gear. Some pretty successful race engine people say that for a FORD, the composite gear is good. Comp Cams suggests it for this type of setup. (Disclaimer) I never willingly use ANY comp cam products.😜
as you know Mitch,my junk is as far from max effort as can be but my comp cam looks real good the last time I saw it last winter when the intake was off.
When I bought my Comp Cams 10 years ago Comp Cams told me not to buy their composite gear so I went with bronze and the same one is still on my dist.
With the max effort stuff you and some others have Comp Cams might be an issue , but for me at my low HP level their stuff has been fine.
Don't get me wrong, and as you know , I ain't making the number of passes & going rounds like @itey , he went 3 rounds several years ago, thats a fucking stress test if I ever heard of one.
 
What ever homo , my junk is track tested and proven . Next time get someone to assemble that engine who knows WTF he is doing. , 3 gears chewed up lol.
Any time or place. How about next Saturday pit spot # 11 keystone.. pack a lunch and bring a friend . That is exactly where I will be , come and look me up. If you dislike me that much to respond to my posts the way you do you should jump on the chance to come see me. If you don't, that shows everyone the soy boy you really are. Internet tuff guy that hasa crocodile mouth and a puppy dog ass
Seriously man, congratulations on going those 3 rounds several years ago . No joke , that's amazing
You are the one who always brings up 'homo' and 'shit talk' and several other 'shit talk' so why are you putting anything on me? The deal with three failed bronze gears was I got the job of tuning the carb and distributor when it ate the first gear. I have no idea who built the engine and I don't care, it runs great now. The gear drama just was what it was, all I did was set up the distributor and replace gears until it quit eating them. The gears were installed to the Ford blueprint specs, so the failures were not because of incorrect thrust clearance. Maybe the bronze gears polished the cam gear. It was a CC hyd roller and tore up 2 CC bronze gears and one MSD. The plastic gear survived. The story is not shit talk. You can make a shit sandwich any way you like, but you jumped on me, I didn't say shit about you until you started your ignorant shit talk. Why do you have to be this way?

WTF three rounds are you going on about?
 
Last edited:
You are the one who always brings up 'homo' and 'shit talk' and several other 'shit talk' so why are you putting anything on me? The deal with three failed bronze gears was I got the job of tuning the carb and distributor when it ate the first gear. I have no idea who built the engine and I don't care, it runs great now. The gear drama just was what it was, all I did was set up the distributor and replace gears until it quit eating them. The gears were installed to the Ford blueprint specs, so the failures were not because of incorrect thrust clearance. Maybe the bronze gears polished the cam gear. It was a CC hyd roller and tore up 2 CC bronze gears and one MSD. The plastic gear survived. The story is not shit talk. You can make a shit sandwich any way you like, but you jumped on me, I didn't say shit about you until you started your ignorant shit talk. Why do you have to be this way?
Really, are you going to pretend that you have no idea why ?

Then today you say in post 186 that everything I said in this thread is BS.
I would not offer up BS as advice in a "real " thread and would never knowingly give Fox or anyone else bad info or info I knew to be bad . The best info is from experience, I am not a baller or wheel max effort rides, but I have a fuck ton of experience with what works and does not . And if something is out of my league like max effort stuff, I do not comment or offer advice.
I am done with you , you know where and when you and your friend can discuss this further with me if you choose to. Oh ya, dont forget to pack that lunch.
 
4 out of 5 PB-ers suggest running the metal out of it. Good enough for me.
Did I miss any info on what the oil looked like out of the pan? Your boat mettalic flakes were out of the filter, correct. I don't know why, but my backwards ass, country fuck mind would want to put the drain plug in, put some diesel fuel in it then pull the plug and flush what I could out of the pan. Don't really know just thinking out loud.
 
Really, are you going to pretend that you have no idea why ?

Then today you say in post 186 that everything I said in this thread is BS.
I would not offer up BS as advice in a "real " thread and would never knowingly give Fox or anyone else bad info or info I knew to be bad . The best info is from experience, I am not a baller or wheel max effort rides, but I have a fuck ton of experience with what works and does not . And if something is out of my league like max effort stuff, I do not comment or offer advice.
I am done with you , you know where and when you and your friend can discuss this further with me if you choose to. Oh ya, dont forget to pack that lunch.
I get it now. You are the only one with any experience. Nobody but you has anya experience or knows anything, so you can shit talk and everybody else can only listen.

You said you are the king of shit in post 185, so I took you at your word.

I don't care where you are, where you will be, or when you will be there, so go talk your shit where and whenever it pleases you.

What a great thread. Has the second oil filter been autopsied yet?
 
Dude you supply more quality entertainment than you'll ever know.
Might I suggest a poll?
Will she blow? Or will she roll?

Since this isn't anyone else's dime, they say fuck it, run it, see what happens.

The fact is the engine is toast and needs to come apart. Will it make noise and go down the road a few more times? Sure. Will the bearings turn to dust? Guaranteed.

If anyone here truly believes that amount of bearing material and ferrous shit is going to work itself out you're crazier than online dating chicks.

After i idle this engine 10 minutes to prove how fuckin stupid i am, this engine is coming out, being stuffed in the corner, and this project is essentially dead.

In case you guys didn't follow along in the build thread.. 3 different builders fucked me, over $20k into this 400hp (not joking) engine. I'm not putting another dime into it.
 
Back
Top