What a pile of questions i have..
What does a distributor machine do?
Trying to wrap my brain around your whole message, you'd like to see 12 degrees advance at 16"hg vacuum. Based on my spring/bushing combo on the turd I have (all in 34* by 3000) it would roughly equate to:
At 2000 rpm cruise with 20" vacuum
16 initial
10 centrifugal
10 vacuum (the max my canister will advance)
Putting me at 36 degrees, but you mentioned a 393 you messed with wanted 22 at 2000.
Am I screwing up the interpretation?
The mechanical curve is WOT RPM related timing. There is no (or very little) vacuum at WOT, unless the carb is too small, such as restricted circle track with a 350 or 500 2bbl or 390 4bbl.
To understand the vacuum advance, you guys need to connect a vacuum gauge to manifold vacuum and see what the vacuum does, how it varies at different RPMs when you change throttle positions, cruise, light and heavy acceleration.
This was the PM post you refer to above ^ the RPM related advance is describing the mechanical advance, the vacuum is .... the vacuum advance.
"The last 393 Ford I did wanted
18 initial, start 1200 RPM,
22 at 2000,
24 at 3000,
26 at 4500 and
28 at 6000 <--(edit-- that originally, in the PM, was 5000)
Vacuum advance 0 deg 8" Hg, start or 1 deg 9" Hg and total 12 deg 16" Hg."
The ^^ advance numbers are in crankshaft degrees.
In the case of that particular engine it was a situation of the 393 Windsor had some generic chinese aluminum head, copy of ?, that were on it because the price was right, and the chamber size was intended for a 5.0L 302 I think, and because the cam timing was conservative it had too much compression for pump gas and knocked like a bitch with the "all in at 2500" MSD distributor with the black bushing 18 degree curve.
... so ... we formed a committee of three of us, one young enough to have good ears, and went cruising around one night with a timing light messing the distributor back and forth while making short 1000 RPM "pulls" in every RPM range from idle to valve float, the purpose was to find the amount of advance which ran OK and did not knock.
It was fun, we spent two or three hours in the middle of the night giggling like it was 1966 again (engine was in a 1966 Mustang). We took notes and decided on how much timing at each point in the RPM range from idle to 6000 or so was the hot setup, then I used the distributor machine to setup a Ford Motorcraft distributor and added the vacuum advance. Ford vacuum chambers are adjustable and I think we fiddled with it after installing that distributor and driving the car some more while tuning the carb.
For a highway car you need to finalize the ignition advance scheme before tuning the carb.