I can say for fact hanging long tits or anything approaching that, turns me right off. Size isn't ever the deal breaker per se, but shape that goes with real world large size can be. I would say in the thread here featuring above average boobs, only about one in 30 is a "meh" but there have been a few posted that I was "meh" on for sure.
Interestingly I read introverts prefer small, extroverts large, on their partners, and it's almost without exception.
As far as big girls, I've has some that were amazing in how they moved, unexpectedly so. It can feel very good. BTDT. The downside is only a very few look good dressed sexy. Or to a degree it's that they aren't practiced at dressing sexy...but no, the potential just is low.
I'm not a lingerie guy, but enjoying hot street clothes that a partner wears is like foreplay for me and I miss that.
I would say I fit the settled category but that the "cost" (loss) for me if she has extra pounds is lower to me than most.
I do find a lot of bigger girls feel cold to the touch- low metabolisms, or the adipose tissue insulates the heat inside the core? Especially in Canada, in cooler seasons they literally feel dead.